Topic, Tension, Thread: an introduction to the EE process for students
M28Student session 11 Nov 2026Past dueInternational School of Geneva - Campus des NationsFinding an argument worth 4,000 words.
The Extended Essay (EE) is yours from start to finish. If you are in the May 2028 (M28) cohort, it begins with a student session on 11 November 2026 M28 · Past due, and the work starts at the official launch in the week of 18 January 2027 M28 · 61 days to go. Between now and then is Sprint 0: Topic, Tension, Thread, and you have one job: find a topic and the argument it could carry. This page follows the slides from the session.
Start with a question you can argue
Cities are warmer than the countryside around them, especially at night. This is the urban heat island: dark roofs and roads soak up the sun's heat and release it slowly, there are fewer plants and less water to cool things down, traffic, air conditioning and industry add heat of their own, and tall buildings trap heat and slow the wind.
Now compare these two.
| A topic | A question you can argue |
|---|---|
| The urban heat island Interesting, but there is nothing yet to argue. | To what extent could urban trees mitigate the impacts of heat waves in urban areas, focusing on the tree-lined streets of Geneva, Switzerland? A claim to make, evidence to weigh, a conclusion to reach. |
Only the second could carry 4,000 words of argument. This year is about getting from the first to the second, and you choose the question.
The EE in 60 seconds
- 4,000 words at most, plus a reflective statement of up to 500 words. Examiners stop reading at the limit (EE guide, pp. 13 and 87).
- About 40 hours of your own work (EE guide, p. 13).
- 3 reflection sessions with your supervisor; the last is the viva voce (EE guide, p. 14).
- D or higher is needed for the diploma. With TOK, the EE earns up to 3 points (EE guide, p. 14).
Above all, the EE is independent research: you lead, your supervisor guides. You choose the question. You find and judge the evidence. You build the argument. That is about 40 hours of your work against three to five hours of supervision (EE guide, pp. 13 and 14).
An argument, not a report
Your essay should "go beyond simply informing the reader about the topic" (EE guide, p. 36). Your research question must "encourage analysis, evaluation and synthesis, rather than description" (EE guide, p. 84).
| A report | An argument |
|---|---|
| Describes what an urban heat island is | Makes a claim: street trees cool the streets, but not enough on their own |
| Lists where Geneva is hottest | Weighs the evidence for and against it |
| Stops when the information runs out | Ends by answering the question |
The golden thread. Your argument runs through the whole essay, and each paragraph passes it on to the next, like a team passing the ball up the pitch:
- Introduction: your question and your claim.
- Paragraph: evidence for the claim.
- Paragraph: evidence against it.
- Paragraph: weighing it up.
- Conclusion: the answer to the question.
A paragraph that only describes drops the ball. The IB calls the golden thread your line of argument, and it is assessed in Criterion C: Analysis and line of argument.
Topic, Tension, Thread, then Pathway
Four steps to an argument. Topic, Tension and Thread find your argument; Pathway decides how you tackle it.
1. Topic: start from what you are curious about
- What do you read or watch about when nobody makes you?
- Which lessons leave you wanting to know more?
- Which DP subject does the idea sit in?
Your essay "should begin with an idea that is generated by your personal interest" (EE guide, p. 20). Example: city heat. Why are cities hotter than the countryside around them?
2. Tension: find where people disagree
- Where do sources disagree with each other?
- Where is the evidence mixed, or missing?
- Try starting with: How? Why? To what extent?
Open-ended questions are "best framed using the terms 'how?', 'why?' or 'to what extent?'" (EE guide, p. 85). Example: do street trees really keep a city cooler in a heatwave, and by how much?
3. Thread: say what you might argue
- What claim might you end up making?
- What evidence would you need to test it?
- Can't say it yet? Go back to the tension.
Your thread is your line of argument, assessed in Criterion C: Analysis and line of argument (EE support material, p. 3). Example: street trees cool Geneva's streets in a heatwave, but not enough on their own.
4. Pathway: choose how to tackle it
- Subject-focused: one DP subject. Which gives the best lens on your thread?
- Interdisciplinary: two DP subjects, intertwined, so that each one shapes the answer rather than sitting beside the other. The IB strongly recommends studying at least one of the two subjects (EE guide, p. 21); at Nations we strongly advise you study both. You register the essay in one of five frameworks: power, equality, justice; culture, identity, expression; movement, time, space; evidence, measurement, innovation; or sustainability, development, change. The framework itself is not directly assessed (EE guide, p. 23).
Either way, be ready to justify your choice (EE guide, p. 19). Environmental Systems and Societies (ESS) is already cross-disciplinary, so it can only be taken on the subject-focused pathway (EE guide, p. 20). A Psychology EE uses secondary sources only (EE guide, p. 56).
Two worked examples
One idea, four steps
- Topic: city heat.
- Tension: do street trees really keep a city cooler in a heatwave, and by how much?
- Thread: street trees cool Geneva's streets in a heatwave, but not enough on their own.
- Pathway, three options:
- Geography: compare temperatures on tree-lined and treeless streets.
- Geography and Biology: could urban heat help a disease carrier, such as the tiger mosquito, spread in Geneva? This would sit in the sustainability, development, change framework.
- ESS (which can't be interdisciplinary): which tree species cool streets best, and is their value as an ecosystem service worth what they cost the city?
- A research question: To what extent could urban trees mitigate the impacts of heat waves in urban areas, focusing on the tree-lined streets of Geneva, Switzerland?
Two subjects, intertwined: a recent Nations EE in Biology and Economics
To what extent did COVID-19 mutation rates (Delta and Omicron) influence the economic burden on Switzerland's private healthcare system compared to Spain's public healthcare system?
- Biology: RNA copying cannot correct its errors, so the virus mutates often.
- Biology: spike mutations make Delta, then Omicron, spread faster and dodge immunity.
- Where they meet: vaccines protect less well, so more hospital cases and booster campaigns.
- Economics: demand surges, scarce ICU beds are rationed and costs climb.
- Economics: read through market failure: externalities, merit goods, information failure.
Thread: the mutations exposed failures that were already there rather than creating them. Switzerland paid about twice as much per head but adapted faster; Spain kept access fairer but strained under the surges. The trade-off is adaptability against equity. Biology explains why the variants mattered; Economics measures what they cost. Neither half answers the question alone.
It was written before the 2027 guide, as World Studies. Today a health topic like this would sit in a framework such as power, equality, justice.
Your turn
With a friend, take one idea of your own through all four steps:
- Topic: what interests you?
- Tension: where is the disagreement?
- Thread: what might you argue?
- Pathway: one subject or two?
Nothing to hand in. Keep the idea in your Google Document.
What happens next
| When | Stage | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Now to 18 Jan 2027 | Sprint 0: Topic, Tension, Thread | Ideas and arguments. No commitment yet. |
| 18 Jan to 4 Mar 2027 | Sprint 1: to a great research question | Starts at the official launch. Ends with your question on ManageBac, agreed with your supervisor. M28 · 106 days to go |
| 5 Mar to 22 Apr 2027 | Sprint 2: to a strong opening third | Your supervisor's feedback comes back by 13 May, before your Year 12 exams. |
| 14 May to 2 Sep 2027 | Sprint 3: to a complete draft | Including the summer. Feedback by 30 September. |
| 1 Oct to 4 Nov 2027 | Sprint 4: to an excellent submission | Year 13. Your submission is due on 4 November. |
| 5 Nov to 9 Dec 2027 | Sprint 5: to a reflective finish | Your viva voce (by 25 November), then your reflective statement (by 9 December). |
Supervisors. Don't ask a teacher to be your supervisor: supervisors are assigned within a week of the official launch in January. Allocation keeps it fair: every student gets a well-matched supervisor and no teacher is overloaded, so asking won't change it. Talking to a teacher about their subject is fine; asking them to supervise you is not.
AI. AI can help you summarise a long source to decide whether it is worth reading, work with sources in another language, and test a thread with the RQ Coach. But "students must not use generative AI to write any part of their extended essays" (EE support material, p. 24). If AI helped, say so and cite it.
Your next step
- Start a Google Document for your EE thinking.
- Keep testing ideas: Topic, Tension, Thread, then Pathway.
- Bring your strongest thread to the official launch in January.
Nothing to hand in. This is thinking time: Sprint 0 runs until the launch.
Think back to the two examples at the top of this page. By January, will your idea be a topic, or a question you can argue?
Everything on one card
- Now: Topic, Tension, Thread, then choose your Pathway.
- The EE: 4,000 words at most, about 40 hours, 3 reflection sessions, D or higher for the diploma.
- The sprints: Sprint 0 now, then Sprints 1 to 5 from January to December 2027.
- Supervisors are assigned in January. Don't ask a teacher.
- AI never writes it: not one sentence. Cite any help.
- Start a Google Document for your EE thinking, today.